Financial adviser Rachael Holder of Tribeca Financial joins Mel Dennis on Property, Straight Up to talk through the bank of mum and dad, downsizing, and how to turn property wealth into a retirement that actually works.
Behind every property transaction there is a story, a big decision, and usually far more emotion than anyone expects. Few decisions carry more of that weight than the two many Australians face later in life: how much to help their children into the property market, and what role their own property should play in retirement.
On this episode of Property, Straight Up, Mel Dennis, cofounder of Domain & Co., sat down with Rachael Holder from Tribeca Financial, the Hawthorn based financial advice practice. Rachael works with individuals, couples and whole families as they navigate the big transition points: retirement, separation, receiving an inheritance, or deciding how to support the next generation. Originally from the UK, she brings a perspective shaped by two property obsessed cultures.
Her starting point is one that underpins the whole conversation. There is no single answer that fits every family, and if you only look at these decisions through the numbers, you will probably miss what matters most.
The bank of mum and dad is now one of the country’s biggest lenders
Rachael says helping adult children financially has shifted from a nice to have into a core part of many families’ planning. Rising prices and cost of living pressure have changed expectations, and the conversation now comes up constantly in her work.
The scale is striking. Rachael points to research suggesting around 60% of first home buyers now receive some form of support from their parents. Treated as an unofficial lender, the bank of mum and dad is estimated to be worth more than $35 billion. And roughly three in four parents who lend money to their children do not expect to see it again.
“For many families and for many younger generations, it really is the difference between getting onto the property ladder and not.”
Rachael Holder
That last point matters. If most of this money is effectively being given away, it needs to be weighed against the parents’ own finances with the same care a bank would apply. Yet, as Rachael notes, family support is usually informal. Nothing is written down and nothing is managed the way structured lending would be.
The ways parents are helping
Rachael outlined the most common approaches she sees, each with its own trade offs:
- Cash gifts. The most common and most obvious. Almost 40% of Gen Z buyers are receiving a cash gift toward a deposit. The trouble starts when expectations are not clearly defined, particularly where there are other children.
- Money provided with an expectation of repayment. It can feel like a sensible middle ground, and it is often chosen when parents are thinking about what might happen if their child’s relationship ends. It only works if it is properly documented.
- Acting as guarantor. Parents put up their own assets, often the family home, so their child can borrow more or avoid lenders mortgage insurance. The risk is real, because the parent is effectively securing part of the loan.
- Accessing equity. Redrawing or refinancing against the parents’ own home to unlock some of their largest asset for the next generation.
- Joint ownership. Parents going on the title alongside their children, buying a property for several children to share, or siblings pooling funds. It can work, but it gets complicated quickly when one sibling wants to move on and the other cannot.
- Rent free living. Often overlooked, but increasingly common. Letting adult children live at home so they can save faster, while the parents quietly absorb the cost of running a larger household.
Rachael joked that many of her clients thought having children was an 18 year commitment, only to find their kids leave and then come back.
Just because you can help, should you?
Not necessarily. Rachael’s view is that the first question should always be what any support means for your own long term security. Helping should come from a position of knowledge and strength, not sacrifice. If it compromises your lifestyle or your retirement options, that is the moment to pause.
There is also a behavioural side that families do not always consider. Most parents want to give their children a leg up without taking away their drive or their sense of achievement. How much you give, and how you structure it, shapes that balance. A gift feels very different to a loan that is expected to be repaid.
The mistakes families make most often
When Mel asked about the biggest mistakes, Rachael identified four that come up again and again:
- Overestimating what they can afford. Parents offer help before they truly understand their own position. Mel shared a familiar example from her own clients: a parent who passed an inheritance straight to a child for a home, only to wish later that they had kept it.
- Not documenting intentions. Without clarity on whether money is a gift or a loan, parents and children can end up with very different understandings, and that can get messy.
- Treating family loans informally. If a loan is not documented and not actually treated like a loan, it may not stand up as one. In a separation, the money could simply be counted in the couple’s asset pool, defeating the very protection the loan was meant to provide.
- Ignoring the impact across siblings. Where there is more than one child, decisions need to be explained, because equal and fair are not always the same thing.
Rachael summed it up simply: the common thread is decisions driven by emotion without the practicalities being thought through. Her protective advice is just as simple. Put clear structures in place, have open conversations early, and understand your own position first. Counterintuitively, it is often within families that structure brings the greatest benefit.
Equal is not always fair
Rachael describes the situation where one child needs help and another does not as one of the most sensitive conversations she has with parents. Most families start from the assumption that equal treatment is fair. It is simple and it feels right: we did this for you, so we will do the same for your sibling.
But as Mel pointed out, it is not always obvious which child genuinely needs support. Plenty of people are very good at looking comfortable without actually being comfortable, and Australians still do not talk openly about money.
Rachael encourages clients to shift from thinking about what is equal to what is equitable. Equal means everyone receives the same. Equitable means each person receives what they need based on their circumstances. One child might be settled with a partner, another going through a separation, another raising several children. It is rare for siblings to need exactly the same thing, and treating them identically can do them all a disservice.
“The bigger risk here isn’t actually about the unequal support, but it’s about the lack of communication around it.”
Rachael Holder
When nothing is explained, people fill the gaps with their own assumptions, and those assumptions are usually wrong. Being intentional and clear about why you are helping, and how it fits into the bigger family picture, is what keeps relationships intact.
The property decisions that arrive with retirement
The second half of the conversation turned to the other side of the equation. Many Australians in their 50s and 60s are sitting on substantial property wealth without a clear plan for what comes next. Rachael says three questions come up most often:
- Do we stay in the family home or downsize?
- If we have built an investment portfolio, do we hold those properties for income or restructure our wealth?
- Do we buy a second home, perhaps to escape a Melbourne winter, or simply holiday differently?
Her approach is to slow the conversation down and zoom out. Before any numbers, the question is what you want your life to look like in this next stage. She then works through three core needs:
- Cash flow. Does your current setup support the lifestyle you want, now that earned income is falling away or gone?
- If your health, family or finances change, do you have options?
- Future needs. What do the next 10 or 20 years look like, where do you want to live, and how do you want to spend your time?
Only once those are clear does she assess whether the family home still supports that life. Staying can absolutely be the right call. The risk is staying by default, with too much wealth tied up in the home and not enough outside it to fund retirement. Rachael has seen clients downsize and feel enormous relief, and others who later regret it. The difference is usually whether they made an informed decision or an emotional one.
When emotion makes decisions harder
Emotional attachment to property is extremely common, especially with the family home, where memories, security and identity are bound up in the bricks and mortar. Rachael sees it most clearly at life’s trigger points: downsizing, separation, and inheritance.
She shared the story of a client who had recently lost her father and inherited his home. We tend to think of inheritance as a windfall, but grief can leave people feeling completely stuck. Much of their work together focused on what the client actually wanted her life to look like, and how keeping or selling the property would affect that. Seeing the financial impact clearly helped her separate the decision from the emotion and reach a confident outcome.
Property rich, cash poor
Rachael’s description of this familiar phrase is memorable: you cannot pop down to the corner shop and buy a coffee with a brick off your house. The paper value of your assets might be high, but in retirement, when you switch from earning an income to drawing on your assets, liquidity matters far more than valuation.
She illustrated it with a recent case. A couple owned a home in Melbourne and another on the Great Ocean Road, and wanted to spend most of their time on the coast while keeping their connection to family and community in the city. Three scenarios were on the table:
- Keep the Melbourne home and rent it out
- Sell and buy a smaller place in Melbourne
- Sell up in Melbourne entirely and use hotels or short stay accommodation when visiting
Alongside the numbers sat lifestyle questions. Did they want to be landlords in retirement? Could they afford to maintain two properties and still live the life they wanted? Modelling showed that two of the three scenarios worked. Keeping both homes as they were would have left them unable to fund their lifestyle, the very definition of property rich and cash poor.
Turning equity into flexibility
For people with significant equity who need more flexibility, Rachael outlined three broad options:
- Selling and buying something less expensive to release equity. The government supports this through the downsizer super contribution, which allows eligible Australians aged 55 or older to contribute up to $300,000 each from the sale of their home into super.
- Equity release products. Staying in the home while using some of its value. A reverse mortgage is one example: there are no monthly repayments, interest accrues so the balance grows over time, and the loan is typically repaid when the home is sold, the owner moves into care, or passes away. Moneysmart explains the different types and offers a reverse mortgage calculator.
- Restructuring existing debt. Reshaping borrowings to free up cash flow, with the trade off of carrying debt into retirement, which many people are uncomfortable with.
Each option tries to solve the same problem: turning property wealth into lifestyle flexibility. Rachael stresses that no single product is best. The right choice depends on your intentions for retirement and for your family, because every option has a knock on effect. Downsizer contributions and equity release can also affect Age Pension entitlements, which is another reason to get advice before acting.
Giving while you are still here
A growing number of families are choosing to help their children earlier rather than leaving everything to pass through their estate. As Mel put it, it is nice to see them enjoy it while you can enjoy it with them.
Rachael sees several benefits. There is real joy in watching what your money does for the people you love, whether that is a home, a holiday, or education for children and grandchildren. Support also tends to have the greatest impact in people’s 20s and 30s, when they are trying to buy, raising young families and feeling cost of living pressure most. And giving during your lifetime gives you far more say in how the money is used.
The downsides are complexity and communication, and above all the need to be confident you have enough left for yourself. As Rachael put it bluntly, once you have passed away the money is no longer needed. Give earlier, and you have to be sure your own needs are covered.
Mel raised another reality: parents sometimes face pressure from their children, who assume things were easier for the previous generation. Rachael has seen it too, and notes that because families rarely talk openly about money, children may not realise their parents could need to fund themselves for 30 years, including travel and potential care costs. When nobody knows how long they will live, planning for that is hard enough without guesswork about what can safely be given away.
Where to start
Mel admitted her own go to question when clients talk about selling, upsizing or downsizing is whether they have a good financial planner. Most have not even considered it. Rachael notes that only around one in ten Australian families receive financial advice, far fewer than would benefit, particularly at major transition points.
Her closing advice may seem counterintuitive. The first conversation is not about the children. It is about you.
“Your driver might be I want to help my kids, but really the first question needs to be about you.”
Rachael Holder
Get clear on what a comfortable lifestyle looks like and what finances you need to support it. From there, decisions about how much to give, and how, can be made from a confident and supported position. When families have these discussions early and everyone understands what is possible, the result is better financial outcomes and happier family dynamics.
Key takeaways for parents and property owners
- Start with your own retirement needs before deciding how much to give. Help from strength, not sacrifice.
- Document whether support is a gift or a loan, and treat any loan like a real loan if you want it to stand up in a separation.
- Understand the risks of acting as guarantor, particularly when your own home is the security.
- Think equitable rather than equal across siblings, and explain your reasoning openly and early.
- Do not hold the family home by default. Test it against your cash flow, flexibility and future needs.
- Explore downsizing, the downsizer super contribution, equity release and debt restructuring with professional advice, including their effect on Age Pension eligibility.
Key takeaways for first home buyers and their families
- Parental support is now part of the market for around 60% of first home buyers, so it is worth an honest family conversation rather than an assumption.
- Be clear on the terms of any help you receive, whether a gift, a loan, a guarantee or shared ownership, and get it in writing.
- Recognise that your parents may need to fund 30 years of retirement. Support that looks easy from the outside may not be.
- If buying with siblings or parents, agree up front on what happens when circumstances change.
- Rent free time at home can be a powerful deposit accelerator. Use it with a clear savings goal and timeframe.
This article is based on an episode of Property, Straight Up, hosted by Mel Dennis and Warwick Brookes of Domain & Co., featuring Rachael Holder of Tribeca Financial. Listen to the full episode. The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal circumstances. Seek independent financial, legal and tax advice before acting.


